A Religious Liberty Battle: New York’s vaccination requirements are putting the state’s Amish communities at the center of a major legal fight over religious freedom, parental rights and public-health authority.
The Dispute: In 2019, New York eliminated its religious exemption from school vaccination requirements. The law applies to public, private and parochial schools, while maintaining a medical exemption. The Second Circuit reaffirmed the law in June 2026.
Three Amish schools and community members have challenged the requirement, arguing that mandatory vaccination conflicts with sincerely held religious beliefs. According to recent reporting, fines against three schools have reached approximately $118,000, with New York treating each day of noncompliance as a separate violation.
The Supreme Court Question: The Amish are seeking Supreme Court intervention after losing in the lower courts. Their legal challenge argues that New York’s law places an unconstitutional burden on religious exercise.
The conflict traces back to a major 2018 measles outbreak in Rockland County. That outbreak helped drive New York lawmakers to remove the religious exemption the following year.
Possible Exodus: Amish attorneys have warned that some families could leave New York if the courts ultimately reject their challenge. Pennsylvania, which continues to recognize religious exemptions, has been identified as one possible destination.
Related News Watchmen Coverage
HHS Ends COVID-19 Emergency Authorizations
Prophecy Watch: For Christians, the dispute raises broader questions about religious liberty and the authority of government. Scripture calls believers to remain watchful, exercise wisdom and stand faithfully by their convictions. Romans 12:2 reminds Christians not to be “conformed to this world,” while also calling believers to respond with discernment rather than fear.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Why are the Amish suing New York?
They argue mandatory school vaccinations violate their religious beliefs.
2. When did New York remove the religious exemption?
The exemption was eliminated in 2019.
3. How much are the fines?
Reported fines for three schools total about $118,000.
4. Could the Amish leave New York?
Their attorneys say some families may relocate if they lose.
5. Could the Supreme Court decide the case?
Yes. The Amish are seeking Supreme Court review.
After much research, the following supplements can prevent Covid and other viruses. My family and I mainly follow the protocol of Dr Bryan Ardis. This is only my opinion based on my own family’s success. Please make sure you do your own research and speak with your medical professional before making any changes to your health routine.
EDTA
Glutathion
NAC
Zinc
Vitamin C (Ascorbic Acid)
Vitamin D3
Quercetin
Cats Claw
Nicotine
Bromelain
Curcumin
Dr. McCullough recommends taking this treatment triad for at least three months for anyone suffering from or worried about post-COVID or post-vaccine syndromes.
Nattokinase, Bromelain, and Curcumin are available over the counter at just about any health food store or pharmacy.
Selenium
Dandelion Root
Black Sativa Extract (may facilitate cellular repair)
Green Tea Extract (provides added defenses at the cellular level through scavenging for free radicals)
Irish Sea Moss (could help rebuild damaged tissue and muscle)
In an acute emergency, if you get Covid, Dr Ardis suggests taking low doses of Nicotine in the form of Lozenges,Gum, Patches for a few days until symptoms subside
Affiliate Disclosure:
Some links in my articles may bring me a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for your support of my work here!
Leave a comment